Red Dead Redemption 2 HDR is ‘Fake’ on Both Xbox One and PlayStation 4, Digital Foundry Suggests
According to Eurogamer’s Digital Foundry, there’s something noticeably wrong with the Red Dead Redemption 2 HDR implementation on both Xbox One and PS4.
Following the game’s release last week, players have reported visual issues with the HDR option enabled. Numerous players appear to suffer from washed out and blurred graphics on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One, and according to Digital Foundry, the game currently doesn’t actually offer true High Dynamic Range as the output is said to be derived from the SDR image.
“Based on the video output of Xbox One X, the output is clearly derived from the SDR image and is not actually rendered with any kind of high dynamic range”, Digital Foundry writes. “Yes, we can hit a max 500 nits, but this is with the HDR calibration ramped up to the max, artificially boosting peak brightness from what is likely a 100 nit source image. The game's recommended 100 setting for LCD screens would see all of our comparison shots on this page present in a completely monochrome manner, signifying an image that is, effectively, an SDR image.”
Digital Foundry continues, “This is not the first game to present us with what you might call 'fake' HDR - earlier this year the Xbox One port of Nier Automata also pulled a similar trick, effectively transplanting the standard dynamic range image into an 'HDR container'. Once active, your screen registers an HDR output from the console, but it just contains the SDR image within it. All of our tests suggests the same thing is happening in Red Dead 2 on both Xbox and PlayStation systems.”
Digital Foundry has asked developer Rockstar to comment on the ‘fake’ HDR implementation and we’ll update as soon as we learn more. Let’s hope that this issue is easily fixable through a patch.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is available now for Xbox One and PS4. You can read our very own review of the game right here.